Like our site's new design? In April 2023, Circa was acquired by Mitratech.
>> Learn More


In the face of rising awareness about workplace inequalities and systemic discrimination, civil rights audits (CRAs) have quickly become a critical tool for organizations aiming to foster an equitable and inclusive environment. While internal audits are valuable, third-party auditors have been identified as a trusted resource for providing unbiased assessments of organizations’ behavior related to civil rights. Given the history of doubt society and stakeholders have regarding organizational commitment to advancing social justice, enlisting the counsel of external experts can be the key to thwarting skepticism and disbelief in the findings of an audit.  

Well-executed CRAs can benefit organizations in several major ways. For example, CRAs can meet the requests placed on boards of directors from stakeholders demanding more action on social justice. In addition to satisfying this requirement, audits have been proposed as a method that can help organizations improve both their diversity and inclusivity (Shepherd, 2022) which in turn may lead to the following:

  1. Increased Employee Morale – Employees who feel valued and treated fairly tend to be more motivated and engaged.
  2. Elevated Company Reputation – Firms that champion civil rights enhance their brand image.
  3. Improved Financial Performance Employers that prioritize civil rights experience minimized legal risks, better sales, and reduced turnover-related costs.
  4. Greater Creativity and Problem Solving – Diverse teams are often more innovative and produce higher-quality solutions.
  5. Increased Talent Acquisition – Inclusive organizations tend to attract wider pools of candidates, especially more junior talent.
  6. Strengthened Customer Loyalty – Demonstrated commitment to social justice can open new markets while solidifying support from current consumers.
  7. Reduced Conflict and Turnover – CRAs can help identify aspects of organizations that need development and rectify interpersonal interactions.

Using an Independent Third Party

In today’s complex corporate landscape, civil rights compliance is crucial. While in-house teams offer company-specific insights, external perspectives provide significant benefits. Engaging third-party auditors for CRAs offers a blend of objectivity and expertise, magnifying the rigor and trustworthiness of the massive effort of undertaking a CRA. External consultants not only enhance the audit’s perceived legitimacy but also improve the quality and analysis of findings. 

Choosing an external consultant to partner with legal partners can result in the following:

    1. Objectivity and Impartiality – Neutrality aids data collection. Data from interviews and focus groups, when gathered by third-party researchers ensuring confidentiality, tends to be more authentic and actionable.
    2. Specialized Expertise – Third-party auditors bring extensive cross-industry experience, offering best practices and benchmarks from various sectors. Their expertise may cover statistical analysis, labor markets, wage structures, federal policy, and talent assessment. 
    3. Enhanced Credibility – External validation strengthens credibility. Using independent experts indicates a strong organizational commitment to thorough scrutiny.
    4. Fresh Perspective – External auditors provide unique insights and solutions that an internal team, influenced by the company’s culture, might overlook.
    5. Efficient Use of Resources – Despite initial costs, third-party auditors are often more efficient, utilizing established tools and processes, thereby saving time and resources.
    6. Legal and Regulatory Compliance – External auditors ensure adherence to the latest legal requirements and best practices, ensuring organizational compliance.

When selecting auditors, prioritize their reputation, integrity, and industry experience. Ensure their audit process is thorough and that they adhere to strict confidentiality protocols. It can also be helpful to construct a multidisciplinary team that provides unique perspectives including external legal counsel, labor economists, academics, and industrial-organizational and social psychologists.

The involvement of expert third-party auditors in CRAs can help organizations gain a thorough and credible evaluation of their practices. While internal efforts are commendable, external scrutiny further guarantees that organizations genuinely uphold and champion civil rights values in all their endeavors.

Our strategic partner, DCI Consulting Group, can work with you to identify the root cause of equity concerns and provide a strategic roadmap for change that identifies areas of concern, goals meant to eliminate those concerns, and examples of how to make progress toward meeting those goals. Reach out to have DCI Consulting help you meet your equity goals.


References: Shepherd, L. (2022). Equity Audits Address Racism in the Workplace. Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM).



Skip to content